Skip to content

From the Pews: A Comprehensive Guide to Mass vs Communion in 2024

Mass vs Communion

Delve deep into the intricacies of the Catholic Mass and Communion, understanding their differences, significance, and the rituals surrounding them. Explore the world of “Mass vs Communion” to enhance your knowledge about these sacred practices.

Mass vs Communion

Have you ever wondered what sets the Catholic Mass apart from Communion, or are they essentially the same thing? While they might seem interchangeable for some, especially those outside the Catholic tradition, there’s a depth and richness to each term that demands our attention. Hang tight, because we’re about to dive deep into these profound spiritual traditions!

Table: Similarities and Differences between Catholic Mass and Protestant Communion

AspectCatholic MassProtestant Communion
FoundationBased on the Last Supper of Jesus.Also rooted in the Last Supper of Jesus.
Main PurposeCelebration of Eucharist, which is central to the faith.Commemoration of Jesus’ sacrifice and a call for remembrance.
Belief in PresenceBelief in “transubstantiation”, where the bread and wine become the actual body and blood of Christ.Generally symbolic. Some denominations believe in “real presence” but not transubstantiation.
FrequencyCan be daily, especially in Roman Catholic practice.Varies. Some denominations celebrate weekly, others monthly or quarterly.
Elements UsedUnleavened bread and wine.Can vary: bread/crackers and wine/juice depending on the denomination.
Open or Closed CommunionTypically closed, meaning only baptized Catholics in a state of grace may receive.Varies. Some have open communion welcoming all believers; others have closed practices.
Role of ClergyOnly ordained priests can consecrate the Eucharist.Depending on the denomination, ordained ministers, elders, or congregation members can lead.
Liturgical StructureFollows a strict liturgical structure with readings, hymns, and rituals.Can vary widely, from very liturgical to very informal, depending on the denomination.
Significance of the AltarCentral to the Mass, representing Christ’s sacrifice.Importance varies. In some churches, it’s symbolic; in others, it’s just a table for elements.
Language and RitualsTraditional, with Latin used in some parts (though vernacular is common post-Vatican II).Typically in the vernacular, with styles ranging from traditional to contemporary.

This table offers a general overview, and practices might differ slightly based on regional customs, specific Protestant denominations, and individual church practices.

What is a Catholic Mass?

All Scripture is God Breathed

What is Holy Mass in Catechism

The Holy Mass, as defined in the Catechism of the Catholic Church, is the celebration of the Paschal Mystery of Jesus Christ. It’s not merely a gathering but the Church’s way of fulfilling her essential promise – offering praise and thanksgiving to God. Through the Mass, Catholics participate in the Lord’s sacrifice and receive the Eucharist, the Body and Blood of Christ.

Table: Structure and Elements of a Catholic Mass

Part of the MassElements & Description
Introductory Rites
– EntranceProcession of the priest and other ministers, accompanied by a hymn.
– GreetingThe priest welcomes the congregation with a liturgical greeting.
– Act of PenitenceThe congregation reflects on their sins and asks for God’s mercy.
– KyrieA litany-style prayer, “Lord, have mercy; Christ, have mercy; Lord, have mercy.”
– GloriaAn ancient hymn of praise sung on Sundays (outside of Advent and Lent) and special feasts.
– CollectThe opening prayer which concludes the Introductory Rites.
Liturgy of the Word
– First ReadingTypically from the Old Testament or Acts during Easter season.
– Responsorial PsalmA psalm sung responsively by a cantor and congregation.
– Second ReadingUsually from one of the New Testament letters (epistles).
– Gospel AcclamationA sung “Alleluia” (or another phrase during Lent) to prepare for the Gospel.
– GospelA reading from one of the four Gospels (Matthew, Mark, Luke, or John).
– HomilyA reflection by the priest or deacon on the day’s scriptures.
– CreedA statement of faith, usually the Nicene Creed.
– Prayer of the FaithfulIntercessory prayers for the needs of the Church, the world, and the community.
Liturgy of the Eucharist
– Presentation of the GiftsBread and wine (and sometimes other gifts) are brought to the altar.
– Eucharistic PrayerCentral prayer of thanksgiving, including the consecration of the bread and wine.
– Communion RiteIncludes the Lord’s Prayer, Sign of Peace, Breaking of the Bread, and reception of Communion.
Concluding Rites
– AnnouncementsAny parish announcements or notices.
– Final BlessingA blessing given by the priest to the congregation.
– DismissalThe deacon or priest sends forth the congregation with words like “Go forth, the Mass is ended.”
– RecessionalProcession of the priest and ministers out of the sanctuary, usually accompanied by a hymn.

This table presents the general structure of a Roman Catholic Mass. Some parts might vary slightly depending on the liturgical season, specific feast days, or local customs.

Mass vs Communion

3 Types of Catholic Mass

Solemn Mass

The Solemn Mass: This is the grand form of the Tridentine Mass. It has more ceremonial practices and is often celebrated with deacons and sub-deacons.

Table: Parts of a Solemn Mass

Part of the Solemn MassElements & Description
Prayers at the Foot of the Altar
– Sign of the CrossBoth priest and server sign themselves to begin.
– Psalm 42 (43)The priest recites alternate verses of this psalm with the server.
– ConfiteorA confession of sins, spoken by the priest and then the server.
– Kyrie“Lord, have mercy; Christ, have mercy; Lord, have mercy.” Sung or chanted in Greek.
IntroitA psalm or other scripture sung as the priest approaches the altar.
CollectThe opening prayer, gathering the prayers of the faithful.
Liturgy of the Word
– EpistleA reading, typically from the New Testament letters.
– Gradual and AlleluiaScriptural verses sung between readings; the Alleluia is replaced with a Tract during Lent.
– GospelA reading from one of the four Gospels.
– Sermon/HomilyOptional reflection on the day’s readings.
Liturgy of the Eucharist
– OffertoryThe presentation and offering of bread, wine, and other gifts.
– LavaboThe priest washes his hands symbolizing the desire for purity.
– PrefaceIntroduction to the Eucharistic Prayer, ending with the “Sanctus”.
– Canon of the MassThe central part of the Eucharist, including the consecration.
– Pater Noster“Our Father” prayer recited or sung.
– FractionBreaking of the consecrated bread.
– Agnus Dei“Lamb of God” litany sung or chanted.
– Holy CommunionDistribution of the consecrated bread and wine.
Concluding Rites
– Postcommunion PrayerPrayer thanking God for the sacrament.
– Ite Missa EstLatin for “Go, the Mass is ended,” signaling the conclusion.
– BlessingThe priest blesses the congregation.
– Last GospelTypically, the beginning of the Gospel according to John is read at the end.

This table outlines the structure of a Solemn Mass in the traditional Latin rite (often referred to as the Tridentine Mass). The Solemn Mass is a form of the Extraordinary Form of the Roman Rite, distinguished by greater ceremonial richness than Low or High Masses.

Sung Mass or Missa Cantata

The Sung Mass or Missa Cantata: Unlike the Solemn Mass, this doesn’t require the presence of deacons and sub-deacons. The celebrant sings most parts of the Mass.

Table: Parts of a Sung Mass (Missa Cantata)

Part of the Sung Mass (Missa Cantata)Elements & Description
Prayers at the Foot of the Altar
– Sign of the CrossBoth priest and server sign themselves to initiate the Mass.
– Psalm 42 (43)The priest recites alternate verses of this psalm with the server.
– ConfiteorA confession of sins, spoken by the priest and then the server.
– Kyrie“Lord, have mercy; Christ, have mercy; Lord, have mercy.” Sung or chanted in Greek.
IntroitA psalm or other scripture sung as the priest approaches the altar.
CollectThe opening prayer, gathering the prayers of the faithful.
Liturgy of the Word
– EpistleA reading, typically from the New Testament letters. Sung or read by the subdeacon or lector.
– Gradual and AlleluiaScriptural verses sung between readings; the Alleluia is replaced with a Tract during Lent.
– GospelA reading from one of the four Gospels. Sung by the deacon or priest.
– Sermon/HomilyOptional reflection on the day’s readings.
Liturgy of the Eucharist
– OffertoryThe presentation and offering of bread, wine, and other gifts, usually with an accompanying chant.
– LavaboThe priest washes his hands, symbolizing purity. Sung or chanted.
– PrefaceIntroduction to the Eucharistic Prayer, ending with the “Sanctus”. Sung or chanted.
– Canon of the MassThe central part of the Eucharist, including the consecration. Primarily spoken, but some responses are sung.
– Pater Noster“Our Father” prayer recited or sung.
– FractionBreaking of the consecrated bread.
– Agnus Dei“Lamb of God” litany sung or chanted.
– Holy CommunionDistribution of the consecrated bread and wine.
Concluding Rites
– Postcommunion PrayerPrayer thanking God for the sacrament. Sung or chanted.
– Ite Missa EstLatin for “Go, the Mass is ended,” signaling the conclusion. Sung by the deacon or priest.
– BlessingThe priest blesses the congregation.
– Last GospelTypically, the beginning of the Gospel according to John is read or sung at the end.

The Sung Mass (Missa Cantata) is a type of Traditional Latin Mass that is not as elaborate as the Solemn Mass but has more ceremonial aspects than a Low Mass. In essence, it’s a High Mass without deacon and subdeacon. Most parts of the Mass are sung or chanted by the priest, choir, and congregation, giving it the name “Sung Mass”.

Low Mass

The Low Mass: This involves no singing and might be considered a more straightforward version of the Mass.

Table: Parts of a Low Mass

Part of the Low MassElements & Description
Prayers at the Foot of the Altar
– Sign of the CrossThe priest signs himself to begin the Mass.
– Psalm 42 (43)The priest recites alternate verses of this psalm with the server.
– ConfiteorA confession of sins, spoken by the priest and then repeated by the server.
– Kyrie“Lord, have mercy; Christ, have mercy; Lord, have mercy.” Recited in Greek.
IntroitA psalm or other scripture recited as the priest approaches the altar.
CollectThe opening prayer, gathering the prayers of the faithful.
Liturgy of the Word
– EpistleA reading, typically from the New Testament letters, read by the priest.
– Gradual and AlleluiaScriptural verses recited between readings; the Alleluia is replaced with a Tract during Lent.
– GospelA reading from one of the four Gospels, read by the priest.
Liturgy of the Eucharist
– OffertoryThe presentation and offering of bread and wine.
– LavaboThe priest washes his hands, symbolizing purity.
– PrefaceIntroduction to the Eucharistic Prayer.
– Canon of the MassThe central part of the Eucharist, including the consecration.
– Pater Noster“Our Father” prayer recited by the priest.
– FractionBreaking of the consecrated bread.
– Agnus Dei“Lamb of God” recited by the priest and server.
– Holy CommunionDistribution of the consecrated bread and wine.
Concluding Rites
– Postcommunion PrayerPrayer thanking God for the sacrament.
– Ite Missa EstLatin for “Go, the Mass is ended,” signaling the conclusion, recited by the priest.
– BlessingThe priest blesses the congregation.
– Last GospelTypically, the beginning of the Gospel according to John is read by the priest at the end.

The Low Mass is the simplest form of the Traditional Latin Mass, characterized by a more subdued ceremony with less singing and fewer ministers compared to the High or Solemn Mass. The majority of the Mass is recited rather than sung. The term “low” denotes its simplicity, not its importance.

11 Reasons Why is Mass so Important?

The Catholic Mass is the heart and the summit of the Church’s life. It’s where we celebrate the Eucharist and the source from which all the Church’s power flows. By attending the Mass, Catholics fulfill their duty of worshiping the Lord and are nourished spiritually by the Word and the Eucharist.

11 Reasons Why Mass is So Important

  1. Sacrament of the Eucharist: At Mass, Catholics partake in the Eucharist, receiving the Body and Blood of Christ. This sacrament helps to strengthen one’s relationship with God and embodies the central tenet of Catholic faith.
  2. Renewal of the Covenant: Every time the Mass is celebrated, the New Covenant made by Jesus during the Last Supper is renewed. This reminds the faithful of God’s eternal love and promise of salvation.
  3. Fulfillment of Jesus’ Command: During the Last Supper, Jesus told His disciples, “Do this in memory of me.” Attending Mass is a direct fulfillment of this command.
  4. Communal Worship: Mass provides an opportunity for the community to come together and worship collectively. This communal aspect fosters a sense of belonging and unity within the Church.
  5. Receiving Grace: By participating in the Mass, attendees are granted grace, which aids them in resisting sin, growing in virtue, and strengthening their relationship with God.
  6. Scriptural Engagement: Through the Liturgy of the Word, attendees engage with readings from the Bible. This deepens their understanding of scripture and its relevance in their daily lives.
  7. Spiritual Nourishment: Just as the body needs food for sustenance, the soul needs spiritual nourishment. The Mass provides this through prayers, scripture readings, and the Eucharist.
  8. Acts of Thanksgiving: The word “Eucharist” comes from the Greek word for “thanksgiving.” Attending Mass allows Catholics to express their gratitude to God for all His blessings.
  9. Reconciliation with God: The penitential rites at the beginning of Mass offer Catholics a chance to acknowledge their sins and seek God’s mercy, preparing them to receive the Eucharist worthily.
  10. Teaching and Guidance: The homily, a reflection on the day’s scripture readings, offers insights and guidance on living a life in accordance with Christian principles.
  11. Strengthening the Church: Every Mass adds vitality to the Church as a whole. As each individual’s faith is strengthened, so too is the collective faith of the Catholic community worldwide.

The importance of the Mass in the Catholic tradition cannot be overstated. It serves as a profound source of spiritual depth, community bonding, and continuity of the teachings and sacrifices of Jesus Christ.

What is a Communion Service Catholic?

For a Child

Ah, the innocence of childhood! For a child, receiving Communion is a monumental step in their spiritual journey. Typically around the age of seven, children partake in their First Holy Communion, symbolizing their deeper incorporation into the Christian community. This rite of passage, often accompanied by white dresses and suits, is a joyous occasion for families.

Simple Outline of a Communion Service

  1. Welcome and Introduction: The service starts with a warm welcome and a brief introduction.
  2. Liturgy of the Word: Includes readings from the Scriptures, usually an Old Testament reading, a Psalm, a New Testament reading, and a Gospel reading.
  3. Receiving the Communion: The main event where attendees receive the Eucharist.

What Happens During a Communion Service?

At its core, a Communion service focuses on the sacrament of the Eucharist. The bread and wine, consecrated during the service, become the Body and Blood of Christ. Attendees then receive the Eucharist, uniting them with Christ and each other.

Mass vs Communion

Eucharist vs Communion

Catholic Eucharist vs. Protestant Communion

While Catholics believe in the transubstantiation of the bread and wine into the actual Body and Blood of Christ during the Eucharist, most Protestant denominations view it as symbolic. This fundamental difference often leads to distinct practices and beliefs surrounding the communion service.

Similarities of Catholic Eucharist and Protestant Communion

Table: Similarities of Catholic Eucharist and Protestant Communion

AspectCatholic EucharistProtestant Communion
OriginBased on the Last Supper when Jesus said, “This is my body… This is my blood.”Derives from the Last Supper and Jesus’ words, making it a foundational Christian act.
SymbolsBread and wine, representing the Body and Blood of Christ.Bread and wine (or grape juice in some denominations) symbolize Christ’s Body and Blood.
PurposeSpiritual nourishment, remembrance of Christ’s sacrifice, and renewal of the covenant.To remember Christ’s sacrifice and proclaim His death until He comes.
FrequencyCan be celebrated daily but obligatory for Catholics to attend at least on Sundays and Holy Days of Obligation.Varies by denomination. Some do it weekly, others monthly or on special occasions.
Communal AspectBrings the community together to worship and recommit to Christian life.A communal rite that fosters unity and shared commitment among believers.
Element of ThanksgivingThe term “Eucharist” is derived from the Greek word for “thanksgiving.”Many Protestant denominations use the term “Eucharist” as well, denoting thanksgiving.
Connection to the Last SupperThe central act of re-enacting the Last Supper, following Jesus’ commandment.Recollection and re-enactment of the Last Supper, emphasizing remembrance.
Scriptural FoundationsBased on passages from the New Testament, especially 1 Corinthians 11:23-26 and the Synoptic Gospels.Similarly rooted in the New Testament, particularly in 1 Corinthians 11:23-26.
Use of LiturgyUses a structured liturgy, with set prayers and rituals.Many Protestant denominations also use a liturgy, though it can vary widely.
Invitation to ParticipateOnly baptized and confirmed Catholics in a state of grace can receive the Eucharist.While practices vary, many Protestant denominations invite all baptized Christians.
Acknowledgment of Christ’s PresenceBelieve in the Real Presence: that the bread and wine become the actual Body and Blood of Christ.Varies among denominations. Some see it as symbolic, while others believe in a form of real or spiritual presence.

While there are similarities between the Catholic Eucharist and Protestant Communion, significant theological differences exist. It’s always beneficial to engage in ecumenical dialogue and understand these nuances within the broader context of Christian unity.

4 Ways Jesus is Present in the Eucharist

  1. In the Word: Jesus speaks to us through the Scriptures.
  2. In the People: Where two or more gather in His name, He is there.
  3. In the Priest: Through the priest, Jesus offers the sacrifice.
  4. In the Eucharistic Elements: The consecrated bread and wine become the Body and Blood of Christ.

What Happens During the Eucharist?

During the Eucharist, the priest consecrates the bread and wine. Through the power of the Holy Spirit and the priest’s words, these elements become the Body and Blood of Christ. This miraculous transformation is the highlight of the Catholic Mass.

What is Holy Eucharist?

Often termed as “The Source and Summit of Christian Life,” the Holy Eucharist is the sacrament in which Jesus gives Himself – His Body and Blood – for us, so that we too might give ourselves to Him in love.

Table: Parts of the Eucharist, Their Symbolism, and Biblical Location

Part of the EucharistSymbolismBiblical Location
OffertoryOffering of ourselves and our gifts to God. The bread and wine are presented as gifts from the congregation.Not directly mentioned, but related to Jewish sacrificial traditions.
Sanctus (Holy, Holy, Holy)Praise of the thrice-holy God. Recognizes the holiness and majesty of God.Isaiah 6:3; Revelation 4:8
ConsecrationTransformation of the bread and wine into the Body and Blood of Christ.Matthew 26:26-28; Mark 14:22-24; Luke 22:19-20; 1 Corinthians 11:23-25
The Great AmenAffirmation of the congregation to the Eucharistic prayer and what has been proclaimed.Deuteronomy 27:15-26 (not directly, but represents communal affirmation)
Lord’s Prayer (Our Father)Prayer taught by Jesus, asking for God’s will and daily sustenance.Matthew 6:9-13; Luke 11:2-4
Sign of PeaceExpression of unity and love among the congregation.Matthew 5:23-24; John 14:27
Agnus Dei (Lamb of God)Recognition of Jesus as the sacrificial Lamb of God who takes away the sins of the world.John 1:29, 36
CommunionReceiving the Body and Blood of Christ, unifying the believer with Christ and the Church.John 6:53-58; 1 Corinthians 10:16-17
Prayer After CommunionThanksgiving for the Eucharistic gift and petition for the fruits of the sacrament to remain with believers.Not directly mentioned, but a continuation of the tradition of prayer and thanksgiving.

The Eucharist, as a central act of Christian worship, draws deeply from the Bible. Its various parts are rooted in the teachings and actions of Jesus as well as the practices and beliefs of the early Christian communities.

Catholic Mass without Communion

Catholic Mass without a Priest

Is it even possible? Technically, no. A priest is essential for the celebration of the Eucharist. However, in the absence of a priest, a deacon or layperson can lead a Communion service using already consecrated hosts.

Going to Mass but Not Receiving Communion

Ever noticed someone not partaking in the Communion? It could be due to personal reasons or not being in the state of grace. The Church advises that one must be free from mortal sin to receive Communion.

Mass vs Communion

Rules For Receiving Communion

  1. State of Grace: Free from mortal sin.
  2. Fasting: Abstain from food and drink, except water and medicine, for at least one hour before.
  3. Devotion: Approach with reverence and faith.

Catholic Communion Service Layperson

Who Can Perform a Communion Service?

In extraordinary circumstances, when a priest isn’t available, a deacon or even a layperson can preside over a Communion service. They use previously consecrated hosts stored in the tabernacle for this purpose.

Final Thoughts – Mass vs Communion

The spiritual tapestry of the Catholic Church is rich, intricate, and profound. The concepts of Mass and Communion, while distinct, are deeply intertwined, forming the bedrock of Catholic worship. As you reflect on these insights, perhaps it’s a moment to reconnect with the spiritual traditions that resonate with your soul.

How to be saved according to the Bible    In order to understand how to be saved, we first need to understand what salvation is. Salvation is when God forgives our sins and gives us eternal life. It's a free gift from God that we can't earn on our own. So how do we receive this gift? The Bible tells us that there are six steps: hearing, believing, repenting, confessing, repenting again, and believers baptism. Let's break each one of these down.     Hearing - The first step is hearing the gospel. The gospel is the good news that Jesus died on the cross for our sins and rose again. This news must be heard in order for us to believe it.     Believing - Once we hear the gospel, we must believe it. This means that we trust that Jesus is who He says He is and that He can save us from our sins.     Repenting - Once we believe the gospel, we must repent of our sins. This means that we turn away from our sin and start living for God.     Confessing - After we repent of our sins, we need to confess them to God. This means that we tell God all of the sinful things we have done and ask Him for forgiveness.     Believers Baptism - The final step is believers baptism. This is when a person who has already believed and repented is baptized in water as an outward sign of their inward decision to follow Christ. Baptism doesn't save us, but it's an important step of obedience for every Christian.     Discipling others -  Finally, once we have received salvation through these steps, it's important that we continue to grow in our faith and share the gospel with others so they too can be saved.      These are the six steps required for salvation according to the Bible: hearing, believing, repenting, confessing, repenting again, and believers baptism. If you have never done these things or if you're not sure if you've done them correctly, I encourage you to talk to a pastor or other Christian friend who can help guide you through these steps. Salvation is a free gift from God, but it's one that we need to take intentional steps to receive. Don't wait another day - start your journey towards salvation today!

Author

  • Greg Gaines

    Father / Grandfather / Minister / Missionary / Deacon / Elder / Author / Digital Missionary / Foster Parents / Welcome to our Family https://jesusleadershiptraining.com/about-us/

Spread the Gospel